Offer rejected on a house? What to do next
A no to your first offer is normal: most opening offers are meant to leave room. In a study of sales in London and South Yorkshire in the late 1990s, fewer than half the homes sold at the first offer, and two in three buyers whose first offer was turned down carried on. Here’s how to find out what the seller wants, decide whether to go higher and by how much, and when to stop.
First, find out why
Ring the agent, or email them. Agents won’t usually tell you other buyers’ figures, but they will tell you what the seller is looking for.
- Is there a figure the seller would accept?Agents often hint at it, or pass on the seller’s own figure: a counter-offer.
- Are there other offers?And from buyers in what position: chain-free, a mortgage agreed, cash?
- What did the seller think of my position?A chain or an unconfirmed mortgage can cost more than the price.
- What does the seller need?A quick sale, time to find their next home, or a date that suits them.
- Has anything changed?A price cut, another buyer pulling out, or a survey on another sale.
Check the evidence again
Before you raise your offer, check it’s still right. How much to offer on a house covers working it out.
- New sales nearbyA similar home that’s sold since you offered, for more or for less, moves your range.
- The asking priceIf it’s been cut since you offered, the seller is already moving.
- Your ceilingThe most you’ll pay comes from what similar homes nearby sold for, not from how much you want this one. A no doesn’t change the evidence.
Raise once, clearly, then stop
Decide your moves before you make them. The offer pack plans two at most after the opening offer: one clear rise, then your ceiling as your final offer, so you always know where you’ll stop.
- Opening offer£432,500Turned down. Find out why, and check the evidence.
- One clear rise£440,000+£7,500About halfway to your ceiling, with your position restated. Turned down again?
- Final offer£447,500+£7,500Your ceiling. Say it’s final, and why: what similar homes nearby sold for. Then hold.
The plan from the guide to how much to offer: six similar sales nearby, an opening offer at their median and a ceiling just above it.
When to walk away
If the seller won’t accept your ceiling, paying more than the evidence supports is how buyers overpay. Walking away well keeps the door open.
- Leave your final offer standingTell the agent it’s there if anything changes, and that you can move quickly.
- Keep lookingOther homes will come up. A seller who said no today may come back when another buyer pulls out, or the home doesn’t sell.
- Don’t go back with lessUnless something has changed, like a survey finding or a price cut, offering less later sours things.
Emails for each step
Fill in the square brackets. Your ceiling stays out of every email until it’s your final offer.
Before deciding your next move, find out what the seller is looking for.
One clear rise, about halfway to your ceiling, with your position restated.
Your ceiling, said to be final, with the evidence behind it.
When they’ve said no to your final offer, and you’d still buy at that price.
Want a plan for the home you’re buying?
The offer pack sets where to open, how far to rise and where to stop from the sales you choose, then gives you the next move and the email for every reply the agent sends. It’s £19 for one home. See what’s in it.
Questions about rejected offers
Why was my offer rejected?
Usually because the seller hopes for more: most opening offers are meant to leave room. It can also be your position (a chain, or no mortgage agreed in principle), another buyer, or a seller who isn’t ready to move. Ask the agent which it is before you decide anything.
How much should I increase my offer by?
Rise once, clearly, about halfway from your opening offer to your ceiling, the most you decided to pay from the evidence. With an opening offer of £432,500 and a ceiling of £447,500, that’s £440,000. If that’s turned down too, your ceiling is your final offer.
Can I make another offer after it’s been rejected?
Yes. Nothing is binding until contracts are exchanged, and an offer can be raised, repeated or withdrawn at any point. The agent has to pass every offer on to the seller.
Should I offer the same amount again?
Only as a final offer you’re standing by, or with something new: a stronger position, a faster timetable or flexibility the seller needs. Otherwise the answer is likely to be the same.
How long should I wait before making another offer?
A day or two, after you’ve heard why the first was turned down and checked the evidence again. Don’t raise your offer before you have an answer to the last one.
Making another offer?
Find the home you’re looking at to see what similar homes nearby really sold for, and build the case for your offer.
Already know the asking price? Work out how much to offer.
The study of first offers: Merlo and Ortalo-Magné, Journal of Urban Economics, 2004, from 780 sales in London and South Yorkshire between 1995 and 1998.