Counter-offer on a house: how to respond
When the seller answers your offer with a figure of their own, the negotiation has started, and you’re closer than it looks. Here’s how to decide whether to accept, meet them partway or hold, with a helper that works out your next move by the same rule the offer pack follows.
What a counter-offer tells you
A counter-offer is good news: the seller is engaged, and has moved from the asking price, or told you where they stand.
- They want to sell to youA seller who wasn’t interested would turn the offer down. Naming a figure invites you to keep going.
- Their figure isn’t their bottom lineLike your opening offer, it leaves room. A counter well below the asking price shows they’ve already moved once.
- Nothing is agreed yetUntil you both agree a figure, the seller can accept someone else’s offer, and you can walk away. Even then, nothing binds either of you until contracts are exchanged.
Decide your move before you reply
Your ceiling, the most you decided to pay from the evidence before you offered, makes the decision for you. The offer pack follows this rule.
- If their figure is no more than you offered
- Accept it, in writing.
- If their figure is within your ceiling and close to your offer: within £2,500, or 1% of the asking price if that’s more
- Accept: the gap is too small to risk the home over.
- If their figure is within your ceiling, but further off
- Meet them halfway, to the nearest £1,000. If they hold, you can still agree.
- If their figure is above your ceiling
- Offer your ceiling as your final offer, or hold if you’re there already.
They come back £3,000 above you
Their figure £423,000, against your £420,000 and your ceiling of £435,000
Accept £423,000
Their counter-offer is within your ceiling of £435,000, and only £3,000 above your offer. Accepting now secures the home.
They come back £10,000 above you
Their figure £430,000, against your £420,000 and your ceiling of £435,000
Offer £425,000, halfway to their £430,000
Their counter-offer is within your ceiling, so you could accept it. Meeting halfway usually settles it for less; if they hold at £430,000, you can still agree.
They hold at the asking price
Their figure £440,000, against your £420,000 and your ceiling of £435,000
Make £435,000 your final offer
Their counter-offer of £440,000 is above the most you planned to pay. Offer your ceiling and say it’s your final offer, so they know there’s no more to come.
In each case the home is on the market at £440,000, and the buyer offered £420,000.
Work out your next move
Enter your figures. Nothing leaves your browser.
Enter all four figures to see your next move.
The same rule the offer pack’s negotiation plan uses. Your ceiling should come from the evidence: what similar homes nearby sold for, not what you could stretch to on the day.
Trade on more than the price
Sellers want more than the most money. Offering what matters to them can close a gap without raising your figure.
- Their timingExchange and complete when suits them, especially if they’re buying too. Ask the agent what they need.
- CertaintyNothing to sell, a mortgage agreed in principle, a solicitor instructed and a survey booked straight away.
- SpeedA date you’ll aim to exchange by, if you can keep to it.
- What’s includedCarpets, curtains, appliances or a shed you’d buy separately or do without. Agree them in writing through your solicitors, on the fixtures and fittings form.
Emails for each move
Fill in the square brackets. Keep your ceiling out of every email, unless it’s your final offer.
When their figure is one you’re happy to pay.
When their figure is within your ceiling, but further off than you’d like.
When their figure is above the most you’ll pay.
Want the next move worked out for each reply?
With the offer pack, log each offer and what the agent says back, or paste their email, and get your next move and the email to send, never past your ceiling. It’s £19 for one home. See what’s in it.
Questions about counter-offers
Should I accept a counter-offer on a house?
Accept it if it’s within your ceiling, the most you decided to pay from what similar homes nearby sold for, and close to your own offer. If it’s within your ceiling but further off, meeting halfway usually settles it for less. If it’s above your ceiling, offer your ceiling as your final offer rather than going past it.
Is a counter-offer legally binding?
No. In England and Wales neither an offer nor a counter-offer binds anyone until contracts are exchanged. Agreeing a price is a sale “subject to contract”: either side can still change or withdraw it.
How do I respond to a counter-offer?
In writing, after deciding your move: accept, meet halfway, or make a final offer at your ceiling. Restate your position (nothing to sell, a mortgage agreed in principle) with any new figure, because a strong buyer can win at a lower price.
How long should I take to respond to a counter-offer?
A day or two is normal. Answer promptly, so the seller doesn’t think you’ve lost interest, but don’t rush a decision you haven’t checked against the evidence.
What if the seller won’t come down from the asking price?
If the asking price is above your ceiling, say your offer stands as your final one and leave it with the agent. Sellers often come back once other interest fades or a sale falls through, and many agreed sales do fall through before exchange.
Negotiating on a home?
Find the home you’re looking at to see what similar homes nearby really sold for, and build the case for your offer.
Already know the asking price? Work out how much to offer.