Sold house prices on Old Hay Close, S17
Sheffield
There have been 25 sales on Old Hay Close in the last ten years, most recently 42 Old Hay Close for £415,000 in Jun 2026. Over the last five years the median was £487,875.
Prices around Old Hay Close
Each square is the median of its sales over the last two years. Hover or tap for detail.
Sales on Old Hay Close
Every standard sale since 1995 (sales to companies and repossessions are left out). Open one to see what similar homes nearby sold for.
- 42 Old Hay CloseSemi-detached · Leasehold · 84 m² · 733 years left on the lease£415,00026 Jun 2026
- 60 Old Hay CloseSemi-detached · Freehold · 92 m²£420,40013 Sept 2025
- 88 Old Hay CloseDetached · Leasehold · 83 m² · 734 years left on the lease£525,00029 Jul 2025
- 70 Old Hay CloseDetached · Leasehold · 77 m² · 735 years left on the lease£499,50017 Dec 2024
- 52 Old Hay CloseSemi-detached · Leasehold · 79 m² · 735 years left on the lease£360,00013 Aug 2024
- 4 Old Hay CloseDetached · Leasehold · 105 m² · 735 years left on the lease£570,00012 Aug 2024
- 37 Old Hay CloseDetached · Leasehold · 96 m² · 735 years left on the lease£525,0007 Aug 2024
- 21 Old Hay CloseSemi-detached · Leasehold · 102 m² · 735 years left on the lease£425,00028 Jun 2024
- 6 Old Hay CloseDetached · Freehold · 141 m²£715,00012 Oct 2023
- 41 Old Hay CloseDetached · Leasehold · 102 m² · 736 years left on the lease£500,00014 Aug 2023
- 25 Old Hay CloseSemi-detached · Leasehold · 108 m² · 736 years left on the lease£475,00016 Jun 2023
- 38 Old Hay CloseDetached · Leasehold · 96 m² · 737 years left on the lease£505,00029 Jul 2022
Show 61 more salesShow fewer sales
- 31 Old Hay CloseDetached · Leasehold · 106 m² · 737 years left on the lease£476,25013 Apr 2022
- 88 Old Hay CloseDetached · Leasehold · 83 m² · 738 years left on the lease£435,00024 Sept 2021
- 7 Old Hay CloseDetached · Leasehold · 91 m² · 738 years left on the lease£466,00025 Jun 2021
- 27 Old Hay CloseSemi-detached · Leasehold · 99 m² · 738 years left on the lease£368,00015 Jan 2021
- 60 Old Hay CloseSemi-detached · Freehold · 92 m²£357,00030 Oct 2020
- 60 Old Hay CloseSemi-detached · Leasehold · 92 m² · 739 years left on the lease£357,00020 Oct 2020
- 12 Old Hay CloseDetached · Leasehold · 137 m² · 739 years left on the lease£555,00025 Sept 2020
- 5 Old Hay CloseDetached · Leasehold · 83 m² · 741 years left on the lease£365,0005 Dec 2018
- 32 Old Hay CloseDetached · Leasehold · 94 m² · 741 years left on the lease£345,00017 Oct 2018
- 28 Old Hay CloseSemi-detached · Leasehold · 105 m² · 741 years left on the lease£406,00024 Aug 2018
- 90 Old Hay CloseDetached · Leasehold · 88 m² · 741 years left on the lease£395,00013 Apr 2018
- 34 Old Hay CloseSemi-detached · Leasehold · 101 m² · 742 years left on the lease£360,0005 Jun 2017
- 62 Old Hay CloseTerraced · Leasehold · 84 m² · 743 years left on the lease£280,00012 Sept 2016
- 2 Old Hay CloseDetached · Freehold · 106 m²£415,00026 May 2016
- 33 Old Hay CloseDetached · Leasehold · 106 m² · 743 years left on the lease£329,75024 Feb 2016
- 26 Old Hay CloseDetached · Leasehold · 135 m² · 744 years left on the lease£390,00016 Oct 2015
- 86 Old Hay CloseDetached · Leasehold · 129 m² · 744 years left on the lease£390,0005 Feb 2015
- 15 Old Hay CloseDetached · Leasehold · 153 m² · 745 years left on the lease£363,0009 Jul 2014
- 80 Old Hay CloseDetached · Leasehold · 77 m² · 745 years left on the lease£268,00027 Feb 2014
- 36 Old Hay CloseSemi-detached · Leasehold · 109 m² · 746 years left on the lease£325,00027 Nov 2013
- 12 Old Hay CloseDetached · Leasehold · 137 m² · 746 years left on the lease£363,55011 Oct 2013
- 66 Old Hay CloseSemi-detached · Leasehold · 93 m² · 746 years left on the lease£239,0001 Jul 2013
- 78 Old Hay CloseDetached · Leasehold · 76 m² · 746 years left on the lease£255,19724 May 2013
- 82 Old Hay CloseDetached · Leasehold · 94 m² · 747 years left on the lease£295,7504 May 2012
- 90 Old Hay CloseDetached · Leasehold · 88 m² · 747 years left on the lease£249,95023 Feb 2012
- 29 Old Hay CloseSemi-detached · Leasehold · 115 m² · 748 years left on the lease£249,95024 Oct 2011
- 33 Old Hay CloseDetached · Leasehold · 106 m² · 749 years left on the lease£272,50017 Nov 2010
- 74 Old Hay CloseDetached · Leasehold£299,5002 Jul 2008
- 29 Old Hay CloseSemi-detached · Leasehold · 115 m² · 751 years left on the lease£269,00020 Dec 2007
- 25 Old Hay CloseSemi-detached · Leasehold · 108 m² · 752 years left on the lease£245,0001 Jun 2007
- 42 Old Hay CloseSemi-detached · Leasehold · 84 m² · 752 years left on the lease£221,97523 Mar 2007
- 28 Old Hay CloseSemi-detached · Leasehold · 105 m² · 753 years left on the lease£330,00031 Aug 2006
- 56 Old Hay CloseDetached · Leasehold · 132 m² · 754 years left on the lease£280,0009 Sept 2005
- 56 Old Hay CloseDetached · Freehold · 132 m²£280,0009 Sept 2005
- 18 Old Hay CloseDetached · Leasehold£345,00030 Jun 2005
- 28 Old Hay CloseSemi-detached · Leasehold · 105 m² · 754 years left on the lease£240,00030 Jun 2005
- 34 Old Hay CloseSemi-detached · Leasehold · 101 m² · 754 years left on the lease£250,00023 Jun 2005
- 54 Old Hay CloseDetached · Leasehold£249,99915 Dec 2003
- 76 Old Hay CloseDetached · Leasehold£210,0009 Oct 2003
- 78 Old Hay CloseDetached · Leasehold · 76 m² · 756 years left on the lease£192,0008 Oct 2003
- 29 Old Hay CloseSemi-detached · Leasehold · 115 m² · 756 years left on the lease£170,0005 Jun 2003
- 58 Old Hay CloseSemi-detached · Leasehold · 117 m² · 756 years left on the lease£164,00010 Mar 2003
- 9 Old Hay CloseDetached · Leasehold£250,00026 Nov 2002
- 54 Old Hay CloseDetached · Leasehold£170,00024 Sept 2002
- 27 Old Hay CloseSemi-detached · Leasehold · 99 m² · 757 years left on the lease£145,00019 Aug 2002
- 78 Old Hay CloseDetached · Leasehold · 76 m² · 757 years left on the lease£145,80018 Mar 2002
- 76 Old Hay CloseDetached · Leasehold£150,00023 Nov 2001
- 12 Old Hay CloseDetached · Leasehold · 137 m² · 758 years left on the lease£215,00029 Oct 2001
- 74 Old Hay CloseDetached · Leasehold£130,00025 May 2001
- 43 Old Hay CloseDetached · Leasehold£127,00024 Oct 2000
- 72 Old Hay CloseDetached · Leasehold£110,00021 Sept 2000
- 33 Old Hay CloseDetached · Leasehold · 106 m² · 759 years left on the lease£139,50030 Jun 2000
- 76 Old Hay CloseDetached · Leasehold£115,10027 Apr 2000
- 25 Old Hay CloseSemi-detached · Leasehold · 108 m² · 760 years left on the lease£110,0002 Dec 1999
- 19 Old Hay CloseSemi-detached · Leasehold · 106 m² · 760 years left on the lease£119,00012 Nov 1999
- 58 Old Hay CloseSemi-detached · Leasehold · 117 m² · 761 years left on the lease£96,00010 Dec 1998
- 74 Old Hay CloseDetached · Leasehold£94,00010 Jun 1998
- 19 Old Hay CloseSemi-detached · Leasehold · 106 m² · 761 years left on the lease£82,5003 Apr 1998
- 70 Old Hay CloseDetached · Freehold · 77 m²£86,00031 Oct 1996
- 80 Old Hay CloseDetached · Leasehold · 77 m² · 763 years left on the lease£82,50023 May 1996
- 7 Old Hay CloseDetached · Leasehold · 91 m² · 764 years left on the lease£94,00014 Jul 1995
Prices by year
The median price each year, and how many homes sold.
- 1995: median £94,000, 1 sale
- 1996: median £84,250, 2 sales
- 1998: median £94,000, 3 sales
- 1999: median £114,500, 2 sales
- 2000: median £121,050, 4 sales
- 2001: median £150,000, 3 sales
- 2002: median £157,900, 4 sales
- 2003: median £192,000, 5 sales
- 2005: median £280,000, 5 sales
- 2006: median £330,000, 1 sale
- 2007: median £245,000, 3 sales
- 2008: median £299,500, 1 sale
- 2010: median £272,500, 1 sale
- 2011: median £249,950, 1 sale
- 2012: median £272,850, 2 sales
- 2013: median £290,099, 4 sales
- 2014: median £315,500, 2 sales
- 2015: median £390,000, 2 sales
- 2016: median £329,750, 3 sales
- 2017: median £360,000, 1 sale
- 2018: median £380,000, 4 sales
- 2020: median £357,000, 3 sales
- 2021: median £435,000, 3 sales
- 2022: median £490,625, 2 sales
- 2023: median £500,000, 3 sales
- 2024: median £499,500, 5 sales
- 2025: median £472,700, 2 sales
- 2026: median £415,000, 1 sale
The homes on Old Hay Close
- the most common rating, 69%
- D
- rated C or better
- 14%
- rated F or G, which can’t be let until improved
- 3%
From the latest energy certificates of 36 homes on Old Hay Close.
The typical home here is 102 m² (1,098 sq ft), going by the floor areas on their energy certificates.
None had under 80 years left, which makes a lease much dearer to extend and a flat harder to mortgage.
From the registered leases of 34 flats here with their own.
Check the lease on a flatCrime around Old Hay Close
- Violence and sexual offences51%
- Public order offences16%
- Shoplifting14%
- Burglary6%
- Other theft4%
Crimes reported to the police (police.uk) in the year to Aug 2026, in the neighbourhoods mostly in Old Hay Close, about 1,700 residents, and 10 reports of anti-social behaviour per 1,000, which isn’t counted as crime. Per resident counts high where many people visit but few live, like a town centre or a station. How we count it
Who lives around Old Hay Close
From the 2021 census, for 1,733 residents.
Schools near Old Hay Close
Primary
England 62%- Dore Primary School0.2 miGood in all 4 areasSATs82%
- Totley All Saints Church of England Voluntary Aided Primary School0.5 miStrong standard in all 7 areasSATs81%
- Totley Primary School0.7 miOutstanding in all 4 areasSATs92%
Secondary
England 43.8- King Ecgbert School0.3 miOutstanding in all 4 areasGCSEs56.1
- Silverdale School2.1 miGoodGCSEs56.7
State schools, nearest first, with their latest Ofsted inspection and 2024/25 results: for primaries the share of pupils meeting the expected standard in reading, writing and maths, for secondaries the average Attainment 8 score at GCSE. Ofsted stopped giving one overall grade in 2024; since November 2025 its report cards grade each area.
Primary schools in Sheffield, rankedSecondary schools in Sheffield, ranked
Stations and broadband
Nearest stations
As the crow flies- Dore & TotleyRail1.1 mi
Broadband
What homes can get (Ofcom, Jan 2026), not what they’ve signed up to.
Flood risk and radon on Old Hay Close
The houses and flats on the sale records. Flood risk is the Environment Agency’s, for each home we could match by its exact address: medium is a 1 in 100 to 1 in 30 chance each year, high more than 1 in 30, allowing for flood defences; its map of flooding from surface water is separate. Radon is UKHSA and the British Geological Survey’s atlas, by the share of homes estimated to be over the action level in each 1 km square, its highest: an Affected Area is 1% or more.
Air quality around Old Hay Close
Defra’s model of the background air in the 1 km square around Old Hay Close, as yearly averages for 2025: beside a busy road it’s higher. The World Health Organization’s guidelines, the dashed lines, are stricter than the UK’s legal limits, where each scale ends.
Council tax on Old Hay Close
Homes in each band from the Valuation Office Agency (Mar 2026), rounded to tens. Each band’s bill is Sheffield’s for 2026–27, with the average parish or town council charge where there is one; a home’s own can differ a little. Look up a home’s band on GOV.UK
Renting in Sheffield
The Office for National Statistics’ average private rent in Sheffield in Aug 2026: what tenants pay on new and existing lets, measured across the whole council, with each change on a year worked out from like-for-like homes.
Shops and services near Old Hay Close
- Steel City General Practice0.6 mi
- Stubley Medical Centre2.5 mi
- Beauchief Medical Practice2.7 mi
- Well0.3 mi
- Totley Pharmacy0.6 mi
- Well0.7 mi
- The Co-operative Food · Convenience store0.4 mi
- The Co-operative Food · Convenience store0.6 mi
- Tesco Express · Convenience store0.7 mi
- Sainsbury’s Local · Convenience store1.6 mi
- Sainsbury’s · Superstore2.6 mi
- Hare & Hounds0.3 mi
- The Crown Inn0.3 mi
- The Devonshire Arms0.4 mi
- The Dore0.3 mi
- Almas Indian Brasserie0.3 mi
- Dore Cafe0.4 mi
As the crow flies. GP surgeries and pharmacies from the NHS’s lists of those open, placed at their postcodes; supermarkets and convenience stores from GEOLYTIX’s Retail Points, each at its own spot, with a big supermarket further away added when none of the nearest is one; pubs, bars, cafés and restaurants as mapped on OpenStreetMap, where a new or closed one can take a while to change.
Deprivation around Old Hay Close
England’s Indices of Deprivation 2025 rank its 33,755 neighbourhoods, of about 1,500 residents each, by how many people lack income, work, education, health and the rest; this one is 29,095th, where 1st is the most deprived. Each line shows one part of the index on the same ten steps.
Nurseries and independent schools near Old Hay Close
Independent schools
- Mylnhurst Preparatory School and Nursery2.4 miAges 2–11 · 176 pupils in 2024
Nurseries and pre-schools
- Kingswood Day Nursery0.2 miGood
- First Steps Nursery School (Dore) Ltd0.3 miOutstanding
- Little Saints Nursery0.5 miGood
Independent schools from the schools register; most are inspected by the Independent Schools Inspectorate. Nurseries and pre-schools are those Ofsted registers outside people’s homes, with its latest inspection.
Questions about Old Hay Close
How much do homes on Old Hay Close sell for?
Over the last five years the median was £487,875. The 4 sales in the last two years had a median of £459,950.
When did a home on Old Hay Close last sell?
42 Old Hay Close sold for £415,000 in Jun 2026.
How many homes have sold on Old Hay Close?
There have been 25 sales in the last ten years, and 73 sales since 1995.
How big are the homes on Old Hay Close?
The typical home is 102 m² (1,098 sq ft), going by the floor areas on 36 energy certificates.
What energy ratings do homes on Old Hay Close have?
The most common is D, for 69% of the 36 homes with a certificate, and 14% are rated C or better.
How long are the leases on Old Hay Close?
Of the 34 flats here with their own registered lease, the median has 733 years left.
What’s the nearest station to Old Hay Close?
Dore & Totley (rail), about 1.1 miles away as the crow flies.
What broadband can you get on Old Hay Close?
Every home on Old Hay Close can get gigabit broadband.
Is there much crime around Old Hay Close?
28 crimes per 1,000 residents in the year to Aug 2026, fewer than the 99 across Sheffield and 84 across England and Wales. The most common were violence and sexual offences (51%), public order offences (16%) and shoplifting (14%). That’s for the neighbourhood around the street, about 1,700 residents.
Which primary schools are near Old Hay Close?
Dore Primary School (0.2 miles), Totley All Saints Church of England Voluntary Aided Primary School (0.5 miles) and Totley Primary School (0.7 miles), as the crow flies.
Is Old Hay Close at risk of flooding?
No: none of the 36 homes on Old Hay Close we could match is at medium or high risk of flooding from rivers or the sea, against 1.1% across Sheffield and 1.7% across England, by the Environment Agency’s assessment, allowing for flood defences. Its map of flooding from surface water is separate.
Is Old Hay Close in a radon area?
Yes: every home on Old Hay Close is in a radon Affected Area, against 87% across Sheffield and 45% across England and Wales. In an Affected Area 1% or more of homes are estimated to have radon at or above the action level, and UKHSA advises testing every home.
What’s the air quality like around Old Hay Close?
By Defra’s model for 2025: nitrogen dioxide 6.5 µg/m³, cleaner than 84% of England and Wales; fine particles 6.0 µg/m³, cleaner than 89% of England and Wales. The World Health Organization’s guidelines are 10 and 5 µg/m³; beside a busy road it’s higher.
Nearby streets
Their sales over ten years, and median price over five.
- Totley Brook RoadS17 · 57 sales£362,500median
- Saxon AvenueS17 · 52 sales£622,550median
- Townhead RoadS17 · 56 sales£268,750median
- Bushey Wood RoadS17 · 58 sales£542,500median
- Baslow RoadS17 · 66 sales£275,000median
- Lemont RoadS17 · 58 sales£205,000median
- Dore RoadS17 · 73 sales£840,000median
- Green Oak RoadS17 · 59 sales£320,000median
Buying on Old Hay Close?
Find the home you’re looking at to see what similar homes nearby really sold for, and build the case for your offer.
Already know the asking price? Work out how much to offer.
Spotted something wrong with these figures?