Rotherham vs Sheffield

Homes in Rotherham sold for a median of £195,000 in the 12 months to Aug 2026, 9% cheaper than in Sheffield (£215,000). Per square foot Rotherham is 14% cheaper: £221 against £256.

Local authority in EnglandRotherham
median price
£195,000
per sq ft
£221
in a year
+1.7%
Local authority in EnglandSheffield
median price
£215,000
per sq ft
£256
in a year
+2.8%

Of 9 figures where one way is better for a buyer, Rotherham comes out ahead on 6 and Sheffield on 2; 1 is about level.

Prices

Median priceHomes sold in the last 12 months£195,000£215,000
Price per sq ftLower buys more space£221£256
Typical homeMedian floor area of homes sold915 sq ft883 sq ft
Prices over 1 yearUK House Price Index+1.7%+2.8%
Prices over 5 yearsUK House Price Index+23.5%+22.1%
Homes soldIn the last 12 months2,5885,070
Typical gain on resaleHomes resold in five years, on their last sale+42.6%+50.0%
Resold for a lossFor less than they last sold for3.7%4.1%

The homes

Homes sold, by type
Rotherham27%48%22%
Sheffield15%38%32%14%
  • Detached
  • Semi
  • Terraced
  • Flat
New buildsShare of homes sold3.6%1.5%
Rated C or betterEnergy certificates of homes sold53%43%
Flats with short leasesUnder 80 years left when sold2.2%1.8%
Houses sold leaseholdShare of houses sold11.4%40.6%
Owned by companiesShare of homes, at least4.2%4.8%
Owned from abroadBy overseas companies, at least0.06%0.12%

Living there

CrimePer 1,000 residents a year9799
Gigabit broadbandHomes that can get it97%94%
Primary resultsMet the standard in Year 6 SATs62%59%
GCSE resultsAverage Attainment 8 score43.445.2
StationsRail, Underground, metro, DLR and tram655

Who lives there

Households, by who owns or rents
Rotherham64%15%21%
Sheffield59%19%23%
  • Own
  • Rent privately
  • Rent socially
ResidentsCensus 2021265,791556,519
Median ageOf residents4237
Families with childrenShare of households28%27%
No carShare of households23%29%

Ten years of prices

Each council’s median sale price, averaged over the last four quarters.

  • Rotherham£194,000, up 49% on 2016
  • Sheffield£219,000, up 51% on 2016
£100k
£150k
£200k
£250k
2017201820192020202120222023202420252026
Median sale price by quarter, Rotherham and Sheffield
QuarterRotherhamSheffield
2016-10-01£130,000£145,188
2017-01-01£130,000£142,000
2017-04-01£129,950£151,000
2017-07-01£140,000£155,000
2017-10-01£133,000£153,000
2018-01-01£135,000£155,000
2018-04-01£141,000£158,500
2018-07-01£142,000£160,000
2018-10-01£140,000£160,000
2019-01-01£135,000£160,000
2019-04-01£144,998£154,500
2019-07-01£140,500£165,000
2019-10-01£145,000£171,500
2020-01-01£146,500£165,000
2020-04-01£142,250£160,000
2020-07-01£150,000£175,000
2020-10-01£162,500£172,500
2021-01-01£163,000£190,000
2021-04-01£175,000£185,000
2021-07-01£170,000£180,000
2021-10-01£159,460£177,000
2022-01-01£166,000£182,575
2022-04-01£175,000£192,000
2022-07-01£180,000£210,000
2022-10-01£184,995£215,000
2023-01-01£180,000£200,000
2023-04-01£180,000£196,500
2023-07-01£180,000£219,995
2023-10-01£187,996£210,000
2024-01-01£175,000£200,000
2024-04-01£182,250£207,000
2024-07-01£190,000£220,000
2024-10-01£198,000£222,500
2025-01-01£195,000£230,000
2025-04-01£195,000£205,000
2025-07-01£198,000£225,000
2025-10-01£195,000£215,000
2026-01-01£190,000£220,000
2026-04-01£187,750£212,000

Their other neighbours

Rotherham against its neighbours

Compare two other councils

Any two councils in England and Wales, side by side.

Questions about Rotherham and Sheffield

Is it cheaper to buy in Rotherham or Sheffield?

Rotherham: its homes sold for a median of £195,000 in the last 12 months, against £215,000 in Sheffield. Per square foot, Rotherham is £221 and Sheffield £256, so Rotherham buys more space for the money.

Are house prices rising faster in Rotherham or Sheffield?

Sheffield: prices there rose 2.8% in the year to Jul 2026 by the UK House Price Index, against rose 1.7% in Rotherham.

Which has less crime, Rotherham or Sheffield?

Rotherham, with 97 crimes reported per 1,000 residents in the latest year, against 99 in Sheffield.

Which has better schools, Rotherham or Sheffield?

Rotherham at primary, where 62% of Year 6 pupils met the expected standard in their SATs; Sheffield at GCSE, with an average Attainment 8 score of 45.2.

Which has better broadband, Rotherham or Sheffield?

Rotherham: 97% of its homes can get gigabit broadband, against 94% in Sheffield.

Sold prices in RotherhamSold prices in Sheffield

Buying in Rotherham or Sheffield?

Find the home you’re looking at to see what similar homes nearby really sold for, and build the case for your offer.

Already know the asking price? Work out how much to offer.